How to Evaluate an AI Search Agency for a Bank

Published September 22, 2026 · Updated October 27, 2026

Key takeaways

  • Most banks do best with an in-house owner and existing teams, adding outside help only for work those teams cannot staff.
  • No reliable published price exists for bank AI search work, and cost depends on scope, platforms, content work and your review capacity.
  • A good RFP asks how the work will be done, rejects guaranteed rankings and covers data, subcontractors, audit rights and exit terms.

Three proposals for AI search work sit on your desk. One says your bank will be recommended in ChatGPT within a quarter. One prices a monthly "AI visibility" retainer without saying what you'd be measuring. The third comes from your existing SEO agency, which has added generative engine optimization to its scope. Procurement wants a scoring sheet, and compliance wants to know what each vendor will do with your data.

You'll reach a neutral decision if you settle, in order, whether to hire at all, what drives the cost, what your RFP should contain and how you'll score the answers. We're one of the agencies you might consider, so hold us to the same questions.

Anonymous agency proposals pinned above a shared evaluation form.
Unbranded agency proposals pinned above a shared evaluation form.

Should a bank hire an agency or build an in-house team for AI search?

Most banks are better served by a split model for AI search, where an in-house owner keeps strategy, product facts and compliance sign-off and an agency covers work your team cannot staff or does not do often enough to build the skills, such as cross-platform measurement. In Minuttia's 2026 State of AEO report, a survey of 599 people in SEO, content and growth roles, 52.8% of respondents said their existing SEO team manages AI search and only 2.7% outsource it to agencies.

Minuttia is an agency, so weigh that. The same survey found 19.4% treating AI search as a cross-functional effort and 9.2% with a dedicated specialist or team. Its sample leans toward practitioners and has few financial services respondents, so read it as the wider market rather than your peers. The most common challenge was a lack of measurement and attribution tools, cited by 40.6% of respondents, so ask every vendor how it would measure the work.

Then there are the skills. In an analysis of 1,175 US SEO job listings by the recruiter Search for Hire, 54.9% of descriptions mentioned AI-related skills such as GEO, AEO or large language models, while only 11% of job titles referred to AI, which suggests employers are adding the work to existing roles. If you build in-house, those skills take time to grow. If you hire, the agency needs time to learn your products and your review process, so build that ramp into your timeline either way.

Pick the arrangement that matches where you're starting, and know its weak spot before you sign.

  • In-house only. Works well when you already have a strong SEO and content team and the scope covers a few products. The risk is that measurement across several AI platforms takes tools and time your team may not have.
  • Your existing SEO agency extends its scope. Works well when the agency knows your site and has already passed your vendor review. Check whether its AI search method goes beyond relabeling existing SEO work.
  • Specialist AI search agency. Works well when you need cross-platform measurement, passage-level content work and outside source alignment quickly. Budget time for it to learn your products, compliance workflow and release calendar.
  • In-house owner with an agency for defined parts. Works well when you want to keep strategy and approvals inside and buy capacity for measurement, drafting or technical recommendations. Write down who does what, so nothing falls between the two.

Whichever model you pick, make one named owner inside your bank accountable for the result.

How much do AI search optimization services cost for a bank?

There is no reliable published price for AI search services at banks as of October 2026. What you'll pay depends on the products and markets in scope, the AI platforms tracked and how often, tool licenses, content and listing work, and your compliance review rounds. Many proposals combine a fixed-fee first phase covering a few products with a monthly retainer for measurement and fixes.

The price surveys that exist cover general SEO and mostly small businesses, and the AI search prices on agency blogs come without a stated method. So don't anchor on a number you read online. Work out what drives the cost and compare your proposals on that basis.

Budget data helps a little more. In the Minuttia survey, almost 40% of respondents had yet to give AI search its own budget, and 30.2% had assigned it between 11% and 40% of their SEO budget.

Smaller groups sat at either end, with 22.9% assigning 10% or less and 7% more than 40%. In our reading, that supports treating AI search as part of your search budget, since the technical foundations of the two overlap. So when you take it to your finance team, present it inside the search line, not as a new request.

Cost driver Why it changes the price What to ask in the RFP
Products and categories in scope Each product needs its own questions, page work and source mapping Price the first phase for a named set of products
Markets and branch footprint Local questions bring in branch pages, local listings and more question variants Which markets are covered, and whether branch pages are in scope
Platforms and run frequency Each platform tracked and each repeated run adds measurement work Which platforms, how often, and how many runs per question
Tools Tracking tools carry their own license fees Whether tool costs are included, passed through or paid by the bank directly
Content and page production Passage-level rewrites, new supporting articles and tables take writing and editing time How many pages per month, and what counts as a page
Compliance review rounds Each round of comments adds revision time on both sides How many revision rounds are included, and how review delays are handled
Outside source work Correcting comparison listings and publisher descriptions takes outreach and follow-up Who contacts publishers, and whether paid placements are excluded
Technical implementation Recommendations are cheaper than changes made on the bank's systems Whether the agency recommends changes or implements them, and with which access

A fixed fee suits a defined audit or first phase, and a monthly retainer suits ongoing measurement and fixes. Be wary of fees tied directly to citation counts. The interagency guidance on third-party relationships warns against performance measures that encourage imprudent behavior, and paying per citation rewards volume over accuracy on topics where accuracy is regulated.

Your own costs belong in the comparison too. You'll need compliance reviewer time, web release slots and product team input whichever vendor wins, and a proposal that assumes none of them is understating the work. Ask each vendor to list what it needs from your teams.

What should a bank include in an RFP for an AI search agency?

Your RFP should define the scope precisely and ask how the agency would carry out and measure the work. Ask, too, how it would fit your review process and handle your data.

Build yours around these sections, which include the items your vendor management team will look for.

  1. Scope. The products, markets and AI platforms in your first phase, and the decision point at its end.
  2. Method. How the agency finds gaps, and whether its advice is aligned with Google's published guidance on generative AI features, a question Google itself suggests asking.
  3. Measurement. The question set, indicator definitions and a sample readout you can inspect.
  4. Content and compliance. How drafts reach your compliance reviewers, whether it can work from your library of approved wording, and who signs off each piece.
  5. Technical. What it would ask your web team to change, including crawler access and page structure, and how those requests fit your release calendar.
  6. Outside sources. How it works with comparison sites and publishers, and a statement that it will not pursue paid or inauthentic mentions.
  7. Data and security. Which of your systems and data it would access, including any customer information, which AI tools it would use on your material, whether your data could be used to train models, its security reports such as a SOC report, and how it reports a breach.
  8. Subcontractors. Which tools and contractors it relies on, including AI tool vendors, and how you are told about changes.
  9. Ownership. That question sets, tracking data, content and reports created for you belong to your bank.
  10. Exit. How your data and materials are returned or destroyed at the end of the contract.
  11. Regulatory access. Acknowledgment that the work is subject to examination and oversight by your regulators.
  12. Team and references. Who would do the work, their experience with regulated industries, and references you can call.
  13. Pricing. A price for the defined scope, with assumptions stated, so you can compare proposals line by line.

The data, subcontractor, ownership, exit and regulatory access items follow the 2023 interagency guidance on third-party relationships, which lists them among the topics a bank typically considers in due diligence and contracts. On 15 September 2026 the OCC, Federal Reserve, FDIC and NCUA proposed to rescind and replace that guidance, and the proposal says there are no generally applicable expected contract terms, even for higher-risk relationships. Comments are due by 16 November 2026. Until a final version is issued, the 2023 guidance applies, so ask your vendor management team to decide which items apply to a marketing vendor before the RFP goes out.

How to evaluate an AEO agency for a bank

Score each agency on how it would do the work. Strong answers explain what the agency controls, bring evidence from comparable work and show how its process fits your review. If an agency promises outcomes it can't control, treat that as a warning sign.

An agency sample pack containing audit, content-review and measurement artifacts.
An agency sample pack with audit, content-review and measurement documents.

Start with Google's guidance on hiring an SEO, since it now addresses AI search directly. It says no one can guarantee a first-place ranking, and if a vendor promises one, Google advises you to find another. The same page suggests you ask whether a vendor's AEO or GEO advice follows Google's guidance on generative AI features, and that you grant read access to Search Console at first rather than write access. Google's guide to its generative AI features adds a warning about third-party tools that claim to use internal Google metrics, since no third-party tool has access to its ranking or AI systems.

Criterion A strong answer A red flag
Promises Explains which levers the agency controls and how it will report progress Guarantees placement in ChatGPT, AI Overviews or a first position
Evidence Results from comparable regulated work, with the method behind them and permission to share Screenshots of single AI answers presented as proof
Platform guidance Cites the platforms' own documentation for its recommendations Sells llms.txt files or content chunking as a Google win, or claims a special relationship with a platform
Measurement A defined question set, repeated runs, accuracy checks and written definitions for each indicator One "AI visibility score" with no definition, or a tool said to use internal platform data
Compliance fit A drafting and review process built around the bank's compliance step Treats compliance as a final approval on finished pages
Transparency Shares every change it recommends and the reasoning behind it Vague about what it will do or which tools it will use
Access Starts with read-only access and asks for more only when a task needs it Asks for broad system access before the scope is agreed

Look for a measurement section that names the question set, how often it runs and how each AI visibility indicator is defined. Before you sign a retainer, consider a short paid first phase on a few of your products, so you can test the agency's method before you commit. Make sure it ends with a baseline and a fix list your team keeps.

Hold every agency to the same scoring sheet, including us

We are a performance marketing and AI search agency, and if our SEO & AI Search services for banks make your shortlist, we expect to be scored on the same sheet as everyone else, data, tooling and subcontractor questions included.

  • A senior strategist leads your account, works with your team during business hours and answers for the plan.
  • Our strategists lead your SEO program and use specialist AI agents for research, drafting and technical checks.
  • Your strategist approves the work first, then your compliance team reviews and signs off.
US Agency Awards 2025 winner, Best Use of AI in a Client Campaign

Best Use of AI in a Client Campaign

Winner, 2025 US Agency Awards

Get a clear picture of your bank's AI Search visibility, competitive positioning, and biggest opportunities for improvement with our AI Visibility Assessment.

AI Visibility Assessment

Frequently asked questions

Should the bank's current SEO agency take on AI search?

It can, if it answers the same RFP questions well. The advantage is that it already knows your site and has cleared vendor review. The test is whether its AI search method adds cross-platform measurement, passage-level content work and outside source alignment, or relabels the existing scope.

Does an AI search agency need full vendor due diligence?

That is for your vendor management and compliance teams to decide. Both the 2023 guidance and the September 2026 proposal scale due diligence to the risk of the relationship. In our reading, an agency that only reviews public pages carries less risk than one with access to analytics, customer data or the content management system, but that judgment belongs to the bank. Settle the access the agency needs before the review starts.

Who should sit on the evaluation panel?

The marketing owner of AI search, someone from the web team, a compliance reviewer and a vendor management or procurement representative. Each sees a different risk in the proposals, and the compliance reviewer in particular can tell early whether a vendor's drafting process will fit your review.

Mike Le

Mike Le

Co-Founder, CB/I Digital and Conative AI

Mike Le co-founded CB/I Digital in New York in 2007 and has helped brands grow through search, paid media and data ever since. He started the agency's AI team in 2019 and later started Conative AI. He writes about how customers find and choose brands now that AI answers sit between them and the search results.

Follow Mike on LinkedIn
Tags:

Copyright © 2026 CB/I DIGITAL INC. All rights reserved | Privacy Policy